Posted Aug 14, 2009 6:04 am PT

uh oh its patrickanator again!

McNabb overrated?
5 pro bowls, the best TD to INT ratio in NFL history? 5 NFC Championship appearances, and 1 superbowl appeaerence? No Receivers other than T.O. in 2004? Overrated? I dont think so, probably jealous becuase the Skins can't find a quarterback huh?

Peace! Go Eagles! McNabb made a name for himself with receivers like Pinkston, Mitchell, Thrash, Greg Lewis. No weapons, thats underrated not over rated

• agree 4
• disagree 0
• = +4
• Sign in to rate this comment

Posted Aug 14, 2009 4:57 am PT

I don't know if I'll get a copy of Madden 10. I only have a PS2 and a PSP. Laugh if you will, but it's my parents fault. ANYWAY, they didn't make nearly ANY changes to the PS2 and PSP version last year. I might pick one up, but probably not. (Oh and if any of you got it for the PS2 or PSP and there are cool changes that make it a lot better LET ME KNOW. Thanks!)

• agree 0
• disagree 0
• = 0
• Sign in to rate this comment

Posted Aug 14, 2009 4:54 am PT

Why didn't the Vikings pick up Vick? They need a QB much more than the Eagles. I mean, the Eagles do have McNabb, (who I think is highly overrated) but look what the Vikings have: Tavaris Jackson??! He is TERRIBLE. The Vikings are never going to win a superbowl if they don't get a good QB! It doesn't matter how fantastic your Running Back is. They won't do that well this year, because of there lack of good QB's.

• agree 2
• disagree 3
• = -1
• Sign in to rate this comment

Posted Aug 14, 2009 4:35 am PT

Mike Vick is now an Eagle! Thats great!


Now people will play with the eagles alot more in Madden this year because I imagine him having at least a 92 speed

Peace! Go Eagles!

• agree 1
• disagree 1
• = 0
• Sign in to rate this comment

Posted Aug 13, 2009 8:52 pm PT

haha. gotta work early tommorrow too
but madden comes first=D
pullin an all nighter

• agree 0
• disagree 0
• = 0
• Sign in to rate this comment

Posted Aug 13, 2009 7:27 pm PT

2 hours BMORE will be on da field

• agree 0
• disagree 0
• = 0
• Sign in to rate this comment

Posted Aug 13, 2009 6:50 pm PT

only 5 hours left! damn too bad i work early tomorow morning but i will get my copy right after! psn. Kingofkings8807

• agree 0
• disagree 0
• = 0
• Sign in to rate this comment

Posted Aug 13, 2009 4:02 pm PT

I review 3 different sites when deciding to buy a game and gamespot is one of them. However, I've found that IGN is more on par with where the game actually rates in my opinion.

• agree 4
• disagree 0
• = +4
• Sign in to rate this comment

Posted Aug 13, 2009 3:37 pm PT

yo man i want to see some actual user reviews because i agree that this years game is already better then last years but got a worse rating, maybe Gamespot wants to throw in a monkeywrench with an average score because they get criticsized for giving it a great score every year? The guy who reviewed it didnt look like he was into football or madden so i would have rather had someone else review the game, especially since i heard eckberg give it alot of praise

Peace! Eagles vs. Patriots Tonight! Wanna see Shady McCoy have a solid opening to fill in for Westbrook!

• agree 3
• disagree 0
• = +3
• Sign in to rate this comment

Posted Aug 13, 2009 3:29 pm PT

thats just sad

• agree 0
• disagree 0
• = 0
• Sign in to rate this comment

Posted Aug 13, 2009 3:29 pm PT

@killazunlimited i agree so much with u and KingOfKinGS8807. Gamespot gives this game a 7.5 and the critic scores are 8.0-8.5!

• agree 1
• disagree 0
• = +1
• Sign in to rate this comment

Posted Aug 13, 2009 2:47 pm PT

Gamespot is totally biased for giving this game a 7.5 especially when 09 which was a sh*t load worse got a 8.0. This game is the best Madden and should shut up a lot of those 2K fanboys. I know no one cares about game reviews, but wouldn't you like a little feedback and insight?

• agree 3
• disagree 2
• = +1
• Sign in to rate this comment

Posted Aug 13, 2009 2:02 pm PT

hahah wow gamespot gives madden10 a 7.5. yeah gamespot reviewers do no like sports games at all. They are nerds how do u give maden10 a 7.5 when Polamalu is on the cover!!! not to mention it has improved a lot since last year. Gamepot your all a bunch of rpg world of warcraft geeks!

• agree 3
• disagree 0
• = +3
• Sign in to rate this comment

Posted Aug 13, 2009 12:12 pm PT

How does NCAA 10 get a better score than last year when they admit its the same gameplay as 09 with only season showdown and create a team added. Yet madden gets a worse score than last year when the gameplay, animation, player progression, and online play is significantly improved over last year. Wheres the consistency?

• agree 5
• disagree 0
• = +5
• Sign in to rate this comment

Posted Aug 13, 2009 10:17 am PT

I didn't expect it to be the best Madden ever...but 09 got a 80, then this one deserves a 8.5 at the least. I'm starting to see a review trend with Gamespot. Halo 3 gets a 10, the worst of the Halos with a terrible, short campaign. KillZone was strong in the same areas as Halo, and it gets a 9? I like gamespot because of how detailed their reviews are, but they're very inconsistant. I think they review sports games because they have to...It seems like everyone at gamespot hates football. But you know what, that's their opinion...I'll make sure to NOT look at gamespot when it comes to sports games...

• agree 2
• disagree 0
• = +2
• Sign in to rate this comment

Posted Aug 13, 2009 9:18 am PT

I really think ian cummings did a great job in his first yr as lead Designer and i love the more "realistic" approach he is taking the series, Give him some credit gamespot and stop whining about ref cut aways.

• agree 3
• disagree 0
• = +3
• Sign in to rate this comment

Posted Aug 13, 2009 9:15 am PT

I agree BigBoi Gamespot really showed this yrs game no respect and its the best madden of this console generation and thats how they score it? And yet the other two sites loved it and scored it high? Something is wrong there.

• agree 4
• disagree 0
• = +4
• Sign in to rate this comment

Posted Aug 13, 2009 9:09 am PT

Lol thanks gamespot....I'm pretty sure the EA haters will love the score. 7.5, this is the best Madden that's been out and it gets a lower score than last years outing. In game advertising can make a game more immersive if not overdone. Wow, but it's ok, maybe all the EA trolls will gather on here, and talk about how great gamespot is. First KillZone, now this? Gamespot, don't review sports games. Stick to adventures, action, and RPG's....any other genre except sports. The only sports review I like was MLB the show....At least give them a higher score than last year.

• agree 4
• disagree 0
• = +4
• Sign in to rate this comment

Posted Aug 13, 2009 9:02 am PT

Don't Know what is wrong with gamespot, IGN & Gameinformer both loved this game, IGN scored it an 8.9 and Gameinformer scored it an 8.75,This madden looks the best in yrs and gamespot showed it no respect, I think there pulling hairs here or they all do drugs all day or it could be that particular reviewer by the way where is alex at? Anyway gamespot stay off what ever drugs you are on because you lost some cred with me, Give this game credit where its do and stop nitpicking and just enjoy it.

• agree 4
• disagree 0
• = +4
• Sign in to rate this comment